Depreciation SLM vs WDV | Full Guide for Class 11 & 12

1. What is Depreciation?

When you buy an asset like machinery, furniture, or a vehicle — it does not stay new forever. Every year its value reduces due to constant use, passage of time, obsolescence, or accidents.

  Simple Definition Depreciation = The reduction in value of a fixed asset over time due to use, wear & tear, or obsolescence.

2. Why is Depreciation Charged?

ReasonExplanation
True ProfitWithout depreciation, profit is overstated — misleading stakeholders
True Asset ValueBalance Sheet shows correct book value of assets
Replacement FundHelps save money to buy a new asset when the old one becomes useless
Matching PrincipleCost matched with revenue earned using that asset in the same period
Legal RequirementCompanies Act requires charging depreciation before declaring dividend

3. Key Terms — Understand These First

TermMeaningExample
Cost of AssetTotal purchase price + installation + freight chargesMachine ₹1,00,000 + freight ₹5,000 = ₹1,05,000
Scrap ValueAmount received when asset is sold at end of its useful life₹5,000
Depreciable CostCost − Scrap Value = Amount to be depreciated over useful life₹1,05,000 − ₹5,000 = ₹1,00,000
Useful LifeHow many years the asset will be productively used10 years
Book Value / WDVCost − Total Depreciation charged so far (reduces every year)₹80,000 after Year 2

4. SLM vs WDV — Key Differences at a Glance

FeatureSLM (Straight Line Method)WDV (Written Down Value)
Full NameStraight Line MethodWritten Down Value Method
Also CalledFixed Instalment / Original Cost MethodReducing Balance / Diminishing Balance Method
Depreciation AmountSame every year (FIXED)Reduces every year (DECREASING)
Calculated OnOriginal Cost of AssetBook Value (reducing balance each year)
Book Value at EndBecomes exactly Scrap ValueNever becomes zero
Best Suited ForFurniture, patents, leasesMachinery, vehicles, computers
Recognised byIncome Tax ActCompanies Act (Schedule II)

5. Method 1 — Straight Line Method (SLM)

SLM Formula: Annual Depreciation  =  (Cost of Asset − Scrap Value) ÷ Useful Life Rate of Depreciation  =  (Annual Depreciation ÷ Cost of Asset) × 100

Level 1 — SLM Basic (3-Year Ledger)

QUESTION A machine is purchased on 1st April 2021 for ₹1,00,000. Installation charges ₹5,000. Estimated scrap value ₹10,000. Useful life 5 years. Books closed on 31st March every year. Prepare Machinery Account for 3 years under SLM.
Working — SLM Calculation Cost of Machine  =  ₹1,00,000 + ₹5,000 (installation)  =  ₹1,05,000 Scrap Value  =  ₹10,000 Depreciable Cost  =  ₹1,05,000 − ₹10,000  =  ₹95,000 Annual Dep (SLM)  =  ₹95,000 ÷ 5 years  =  ₹19,000 per year (FIXED every year)

Dr.     Machinery Account     Cr.

Dr.Cr.
DateParticularsAmount (₹)DateParticularsAmount (₹)
Year 2021-22  Year 2021-22  
Apr 1Bank A/c1,05,000Mar 31Depreciation A/c19,000
Year 2022-23  Mar 31Balance c/d86,000
Apr 1Balance b/d86,000Year 2022-23  
Year 2023-24  Mar 31Depreciation A/c19,000
Apr 1Balance b/d67,000Mar 31Balance c/d67,000
   Year 2023-24  
   Mar 31Depreciation A/c19,000
   Mar 31Balance c/d48,000
✅  Note: Depreciation is ₹19,000 every year — FIXED under SLM. Book Value reduces by equal amount each year.

6. Method 2 — Written Down Value Method (WDV)

WDV Formula: Annual Depreciation  =  Book Value at Beginning of Year × Rate ÷ 100 (Note: Book Value reduces every year, so Depreciation also reduces!)

Level 2 — WDV Basic (3-Year Ledger)

QUESTION A machine purchased on 1st April 2021 for ₹1,00,000. Depreciation charged at 20% p.a. under WDV method. Books closed 31st March. Prepare Machinery Account for 3 years.
Working — WDV Year-wise Calculation Year 1: ₹1,00,000 × 20%  =  ₹20,000  →  Book Value  =  ₹80,000 Year 2:    ₹80,000 × 20%  =  ₹16,000  →  Book Value  =  ₹64,000 Year 3:    ₹64,000 × 20%  =  ₹12,800  →  Book Value  =  ₹51,200

Dr.     Machinery Account     Cr.

Dr.Cr.
DateParticularsAmount (₹)DateParticularsAmount (₹)
Year 2021-22  Year 2021-22  
Apr 1Bank A/c1,00,000Mar 31Depreciation A/c20,000
Year 2022-23  Mar 31Balance c/d80,000
Apr 1Balance b/d80,000Year 2022-23  
Year 2023-24  Mar 31Depreciation A/c16,000
Apr 1Balance b/d64,000Mar 31Balance c/d64,000
   Year 2023-24  
   Mar 31Depreciation A/c12,800
   Mar 31Balance c/d51,200
✅  Note: Depreciation DECREASES every year under WDV → ₹20,000 → ₹16,000 → ₹12,800. This is the key difference from SLM!

7. Level 3 — Mid-Year Purchase (Proportionate Months)

QUESTION Machinery purchased on 1st July 2021 for ₹60,000. Depreciation @ 10% p.a. SLM. Books closed 31st March every year. Prepare Machinery Account for 2 years.
Working — Proportionate Months Year 1 (Jul 2021 → Mar 2022)  =  9 months only Dep  =  ₹60,000 × 10% × 9/12  =  ₹4,500 Year 2 (Apr 2022 → Mar 2023)  =  12 months (full year) Dep  =  ₹60,000 × 10%  =  ₹6,000

Dr.   Machinery Account    Cr.

Dr.Cr.
DateParticularsAmount (₹)DateParticularsAmount (₹)
Year 2021-22  Year 2021-22 (9 months)  
Jul 1Bank A/c60,000Mar 31Depreciation A/c (9 months)4,500
Year 2022-23  Mar 31Balance c/d55,500
Apr 1Balance b/d55,500Year 2022-23 (12 months)  
   Mar 31Depreciation A/c (12 months)6,000
   Mar 31Balance c/d49,500

8. Level 4 — Addition of Asset During the Year

QUESTION On 1st April 2021, machinery purchased for ₹80,000. On 1st October 2021, additional machinery purchased for ₹40,000. Depreciation @ 10% p.a. SLM. Books closed 31st March. Prepare account for 2 years.
Working — Year-wise Depreciation Year 1 (2021-22):   Old Machine  =  ₹80,000 × 10% × 12/12  =  ₹8,000   New Machine  =  ₹40,000 × 10% × 6/12   =  ₹2,000  (Oct to Mar = 6 months)   Total Year 1 Depreciation  =  ₹10,000 Year 2 (2022-23):   Old Machine  =  ₹80,000 × 10%  =  ₹8,000   New Machine  =  ₹40,000 × 10%  =  ₹4,000   Total Year 2 Depreciation  =  ₹12,000

Dr.    Machinery Account       Cr.

Dr.Cr.
DateParticularsAmount (₹)DateParticularsAmount (₹)
Year 2021-22  Year 2021-22  
Apr 1Bank A/c (Old Machine)80,000Mar 31Depreciation A/c10,000
Oct 1Bank A/c (New Machine)40,000Mar 31Balance c/d1,10,000
 Total1,20,000 Total1,20,000
Year 2022-23  Year 2022-23  
Apr 1Balance b/d1,10,000Mar 31Depreciation A/c12,000
 Total1,10,000Mar 31Balance c/d98,000
    Total1,10,000

9. Level 5 — Sale of Asset (Profit or Loss on Sale)

Steps for Sale of Asset (Always follow this order): Step 1: Charge depreciation up to date of sale Step 2: Calculate Book Value on date of sale Step 3: Compare Sale Price vs Book Value Step 4: Difference = Profit (if SP > BV) or Loss (if SP < BV) Step 5: Transfer to Profit & Loss Account
QUESTION Machinery purchased on 1st April 2020 for ₹1,20,000. Depreciation @ 10% p.a. SLM. On 30th September 2022, machine sold for ₹85,000. Books closed 31st March. Show Machinery Account.
Working — Step by Step Annual Dep (SLM)  =  ₹1,20,000 × 10%  =  ₹12,000 Year 1 (2020-21):  Dep  =  ₹12,000  →  BV  =  ₹1,08,000 Year 2 (2021-22):  Dep  =  ₹12,000  →  BV  =  ₹96,000 Year 3 (Apr–Sep 2022 = 6 months):  Dep  =  ₹12,000 × 6/12  =  ₹6,000 Book Value on sale date  =  ₹96,000 − ₹6,000  =  ₹90,000 Sale Price  =  ₹85,000  |  Book Value  =  ₹90,000 LOSS ON SALE  =  ₹90,000 − ₹85,000  =  ₹5,000

Dr.  Machinery Account    Cr.

Dr.Cr.
DateParticularsAmount (₹)DateParticularsAmount (₹)
Year 2020-21  Year 2020-21  
Apr 1Bank A/c1,20,000Mar 31Depreciation A/c12,000
Year 2021-22  Mar 31Balance c/d1,08,000
Apr 1Balance b/d1,08,000Year 2021-22  
Year 2022-23  Mar 31Depreciation A/c12,000
Apr 1Balance b/d96,000Mar 31Balance c/d96,000
   Year 2022-23 (Sold — 6 months)  
   Sep 30Depreciation A/c (6 months)6,000
   Sep 30Bank A/c (Sale Proceeds)85,000
   Sep 30Loss on Sale (P&L A/c)5,000
✅  Note: Loss on Sale  =  Book Value (₹90,000) − Sale Price (₹85,000)  =  ₹5,000. Transferred to Profit & Loss Account.

10. Level 6 — Change of Method: SLM to WDV (Retrospective)

⚠️  This is the HARDEST question type — 90% of students fail this! Master it here. Step 1: Find depreciation already charged under OLD method (total) Step 2: Find depreciation that SHOULD have been charged under NEW method Step 3: Difference = Short Charged or Excess Charged Step 4: Adjust in current year P&L Account Step 5: New book value = WDV book value going forward
QUESTION Machine purchased on 1st April 2020 for ₹2,00,000. Scrap value ₹20,000. Life 9 years. Depreciation charged under SLM for 3 years. From 1st April 2023, company decides to change to WDV @ 20% p.a. with retrospective effect. Show the adjustment entry and Machinery Account for year 2023-24.
Step 1 — SLM Already Charged (3 Years) Annual SLM  =  (₹2,00,000 − ₹20,000) ÷ 9  =  ₹20,000 per year 3 Years SLM Depreciation  =  ₹20,000 × 3  =  ₹60,000 Book Value as per SLM after 3 years  =  ₹2,00,000 − ₹60,000  =  ₹1,40,000
Step 2 — WDV That SHOULD Have Been Charged (3 Years) Year 1: ₹2,00,000 × 20%  =  ₹40,000  →  BV  =  ₹1,60,000 Year 2: ₹1,60,000 × 20%  =  ₹32,000  →  BV  =  ₹1,28,000 Year 3: ₹1,28,000 × 20%  =  ₹25,600  →  BV  =  ₹1,02,400 Total WDV for 3 years  =  ₹97,600
Step 3 & 4 — Difference and Adjustment WDV Depreciation (should have been)  =  ₹97,600 SLM Depreciation (already charged)    =  ₹60,000 Short Charged  =  ₹37,600  →  Debit Profit & Loss A/c Adjustment Entry:  Profit & Loss A/c Dr.  ₹37,600  |  To Machinery A/c  ₹37,600 New Book Value from 1st April 2023  =  ₹1,02,400 (WDV after 3 years) Year 4 Depreciation (WDV)  =  ₹1,02,400 × 20%  =  ₹20,480

Dr.   Machinery Account (Year 2023-24)    Cr.

Dr.Cr.
DateParticularsAmount (₹)DateParticularsAmount (₹)
Year 2023-24  Year 2023-24  
Apr 1Balance b/d (SLM BV)1,40,000Apr 1P&L A/c (Adjustment)37,600
 Total1,40,000Mar 31Depreciation A/c (WDV)20,480
   Mar 31Balance c/d81,920
    Total1,40,000

11. Level 7 — Find Rate of Depreciation (Reverse Calculation)

QUESTION A machine was purchased for ₹1,00,000 on 1st April 2020. After 3 years the book value is ₹51,200 under WDV method. Find the rate of depreciation.
Working — Reverse WDV Formula Under WDV after n years:  BV  =  Cost × (1 − r/100)ⁿ 51,200  =  1,00,000 × (1 − r/100)³ (1 − r/100)³  =  51,200 ÷ 1,00,000  =  0.512 (1 − r/100)  =  Cube Root of 0.512  =  0.8 r/100  =  1 − 0.8  =  0.2 Rate  =  0.2 × 100  =  20% p.a.
Verification — Confirm the Answer Year 1: ₹1,00,000 × 20%  =  ₹20,000  →  BV  =  ₹80,000 Year 2:    ₹80,000 × 20%  =  ₹16,000  →  BV  =  ₹64,000 Year 3:    ₹64,000 × 20%  =  ₹12,800  →  BV  =  ₹51,200  ✅ CORRECT!

12. Depreciation Schedule — Fixed Asset Register (WDV)

Asset purchased on 18-Sep-2016  |  Year 1 prorated for 195 days  |  Financial Year: April – March

YearOpening Value (₹)Date of PurchasePurchase Amount (₹)Days UsedDepreciation (₹)Closing Value (₹)
2016–1718-09-201610,00,00019580,1379,19,863
2017–189,19,8633651,50,0007,69,863
2018–197,69,8633651,50,0006,19,863
2019–206,19,8633651,50,0004,69,863
2020–214,69,8633651,50,0003,19,863
📊  Total Depreciation Charged over 5 years  =  ₹6,80,137  |  All amounts in Indian Rupees (₹)

13. Master Formula Card — Stick This on Your Wall!

FormulaExpression
SLM Annual Depreciation(Cost − Scrap Value) ÷ Useful Life
WDV Annual DepreciationBook Value × Rate ÷ 100
Profit on SaleSale Price − Book Value  (when SP > BV)
Loss on SaleBook Value − Sale Price  (when BV > SP)
Change of Method AdjustmentWDV total − SLM total  (if +ve → debit P&L)
Rate of WDV[1 − (Scrap ÷ Cost)^(1/n)] × 100

14. Common Mistakes — Avoid in Board Exams!

Mistake Students MakeCorrect Approach
Using Cost instead of Book Value in WDVAlways use beginning book value of that year
Not prorating mid-year purchaseCalculate months from purchase date to year end
Forgetting scrap value in SLMSLM always deducts scrap before dividing
In change of method — adjusting wrong wayWDV > SLM = short charged = debit P&L
Sale — not charging depreciation till sale dateAlways charge dep up to date of sale first
Provision method — crediting asset A/cIn provision method, asset stays at COST always

Conclusion

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top